* * *
Search by location
Search by venue type
Search by cuisine type
Links
Contact
Guestbook
What's New
 
 
 
 
Quicksearch Sussex Towns:
West Sussex

East Sussex

The Sussex Eating Out Guide

Home> Search By Location> East Sussex> Brighton

> Earth & Stars

46 Windsor St, Brighton, East Sussex BN1 1RJ

Review:

What makes the Earth & Stars so disappointing as a place to eat out, is that it would be so easy for the owners to make this somewhere *really special*. Designed as an eco-friendly pub, with its own solar panels, a recycling policy and a purveyor of organic produce only, this should have been heaving with customers on a sunday lunchtime in December. Instead, there were only a handful of occupied tables, and although it started filling up later, this was only further evidence to me that this is a pub first and foremost, and a food venue second. Not that that's a bad thing, but I can't help thinking that this is a crying shame in terms of missed opportunity. In Brighton, an organic hippy pub selling really good food should be as popular as Infinity Foods or Waikikamookau.

And the shame of it is, the food really IS good. On sundays, they only serve roasts. There's no starters or puddings available, and only one vegetarian option - another disappointing aspect. The spinach and mushroom pie was served with one solitary yorkshire pudding, some scrummy roast and boiled potatoes, exceedingly tasty fresh petit pois, carrots, red cabbage, and some delicious gravy. Rhandolph got the same veg, with pork, although he could have had beef, lamb or chicken.

There is also no wine list - and organic wine option comes in two kinds, red or white. Not such a hot selection for a pub that prides itself on offering organic booze. The three-sided bar only has draft booze on one side - two lagers, two beers, one absolutely vile 'vintage' cider, and some other stuff that costs up to £3.50 a pint.

The bar staff were friendly enough but considering they weren't overloaded with customers, it was a surprise that it took them an hour to clear the plates after we'd finished. We weren't offered any condiments with our meal and had to search to find a meagre offering of mint or horseradish sauce. Not even a single mustard on offer, which again, when you think of the huge range of organic condiments, is disappointing.

The decor is quite modern, with rustic style tables and benches, and an 'olde worlde' map painted on the walls. The toilets were classic pub loos, the paint a nasty off-white colour.

My summary would be - 'could do better'.

 
Opening Times: Mon-Sat 11am-11pm, Sun 12pm-10.30pm
Score: Overall 6/10
Other Reviews:

Itchy Brighton

Rhandolph's review